Robot Wars Good for Soldiers, Bad for Civilians

Monday, April 20, 2009
Reaper unmanned aerial vehicle

The growing use of robots by the U.S. military to reduce battlefield casualties is coming at the expense of civilians, and it could have ramifications as well for the ability of the government to sell future wars to the American people. In 2008, the Defense Department launched 71 unmanned Predator drones in Iraq and Afghanistan—a 94% increase from 2007—to carryout bombing and reconnaissance missions. In addition, the CIA utilized the same drones more than 40 times in Pakistan against Taliban and al Qaeda targets. This growing trend of substituting robots for manned missions is helping to lower deaths and injuries for military personnel, but at the same time it is expanding the number of civilian casualties. British media accounts out of Pakistan claim the use of aerial drones, along with artillery bombing by the local army, has helped drive one million Pakistanis from their homes.

 
As the United States grows more reliant on military robotics, American civilians could also pay a price. “If people know that they are going to be killed by these robots,” Fr. G. Simon Harak, director of the Marquette University Center for Peacemaking, told The Indypendent, “then why would they not therefore retaliate against civilian centers in the United States? It only makes military sense that they’ll find where we are vulnerable.”
 
If robots can increasingly take the place of soldiers, and lower the numbers of body bags coming home, the American public could feel even more distanced from the human consequences of war policy, and policymakers might well have find less opposition to using military power around the world.
-Noel Brinkerhoff
 
Robot Wars (by Eric Stoner, The Indypendent)

Comments

Buford Gooch 15 years ago
Poppycock! I see no statistics in this piece that show any increase in civilian casualties. It's purely subjective opinion. There are questions to be answered here. How do we define "civilian" in a non-traditional combat situation? What is the rate of civilian casualties compared to other means?

Leave a comment